About Callie
Instagram Pinterest YouTube TikTok
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Binge Worthy Bites

  • Recipes
  • Shop
  • About
  • Contact
  • Video
menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipes
  • Shop
  • About
  • Contact
  • Video
  • Let's Connect!

    • Bloglovin
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube
  • ×
    Home » Dessert

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Oreo Ice Cream Cake

    August 27, 2021 | Jump to Recipe | Print Recipe

    41 shares
    • Facebook
    • Email

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Oreo Ice Cream Cake is a cold, sweet, salty, crunchy, creamy, show stopping dessert. It's versatile because you get to pick whatever flavors you want, and create the perfect combination of all of your favorites. Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Oreo, Cookies and Cream and Cookie Dough explosion, and Neapolitan layers are just a few of the versions of this ice cream cake I have experimented with. So let's begin!

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake

    The only thing better than ice cream cake is homemade ice cream cake because you control the layers. Pick favorite flavors, favorite toppings, and favorite garnishes to take it to the next level. To make this combination, peanut butter is scattered throughout, alongside hot fudge, vanilla ice cream, and chocolate ice cream. A crushed Nutter Butter and peanut butter crumble are the crust, and the cake is topped and layered with an Oreo and hot fudge crumble. This cake is drizzled in hot fudge and peanut butter, then sprinkled with remaining crumbles, and finally garnished with whipped cream and pretzels.

    Key Components to Homemade Ice Cream Cake

    Springform pan and ice cream sandwiches quartered to prepare for Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake

    First of all, there are a few tips that make life considerably easier when you assemble an ice cream cake. Most importantly, use a spring form pan sprayed with cooking spray and cut thick strips of parchment paper to place along the inside edges. The parchment paper prevents the ice cream sandwiches from sticking to the pan, and it creates a barrier between the cooking spray and the ice cream.

    Second, use quartered ice cream sandwiches to line the outer edge of the cake. The ice cream sandwiches provide an instant support structure and compliment the flavors of the cake. Use a sharp knife to cut the sandwiches to mitigate smashing them as you cut them. Quartering the ice cream sandwiches is very important because the quartered pieces stand flush to the height of the pan.

    Third, use a food processor to make the cookie crumbles. The filling of an Oreo and the filling of a Nutter Butter provide binding, but also make it harder to crush them into small pieces. The food processor speeds up the process considerably, and the separate crumble mixtures store well in sealed containers.

    Last, figure out the layers, and then write them down ahead of time. Take out frozen ingredients in the order needed to avoid excessive melting. For example, prepare the spring form pan, line it with the ice cream sandwich pieces, and put it in the freezer. Next, remove the ice cream from the freezer and allow it to sit as you prepare the cookie crumbles. As the ice cream sits and softens, it will be easier to spread into layers.

    Peanut Butter Crumble

    Before you begin to make the crumbles, remove the ice cream for layering from the freezer. Now it's time to make the first cookie crumble. Nutter Butters make the perfect combination of salty and sweet and the best cookie crust.

    Nutter Butter cookies, milk, butter, and peanut butter to make the Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake crust and crumble

    Add 12 Nutter Butter Cookies to the food processor, and pulse the processor until the cookies are all small crumbs. Add peanut butter and melted butter for a soft binding, and pulse again until well combined. Remove the peanut butter cookie crumble from the food processor, and then clean the food processor to move on to the Oreo Cookie crumble.

    Prepare the Oreo Cookie Crumble

    After the food processor has been cleaned out, add 12 Oreo cookies to it and pulse until all of the cookies have been pulverized. Add melted butter, milk, and hot fudge to food processor, and pulse until everything is well combined, and then transfer Oreo Cookie crumble to another bowl.

    Begin Assembling Ice Cream Cake Layers

    As the ice cream softens, scoop some of the prepared peanut butter crumble into the bottom of the pan. All of the layers of this ice cream cake will work within the border of the ice cream sandwiches. You will not go above or below the ice cream cookie edges. Press the crumble down into an even layer and use the bottom of a round cup or glass to get it nice and smooth. Reserve some of the crumble for the top of the cake.

    Next, warm hot fudge sundae topping and stir in the container so that it's easily spreadable. Spoon a thin, even layer of hot fudge on top of the peanut butter cookie crust.

    After the hot fudge layer is in place, stir the chocolate ice cream in its container or in a separate bowl to help soften and reincorporate any melted ice cream. Using a spoon or silicone spatula, spread chocolate ice cream into a layer on top of the hot fudge (roughly 1 pint worth of ice cream). Place any remaining chocolate ice cream back in the freezer.

    Peanut butter crumble, hot fudgy oreo, chocolate ice cream, vanilla ice cream, ice cream sandwiches to make Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake

    Now, stir the vanilla ice cream in its container or a separate bowl. Spread a layer of vanilla on top of the chocolate. Again, use approximately a pint of ice cream and then place the remaining vanilla ice cream back in the freezer. Place the ice cream cake in the freezer for 10-15 minutes before moving on to the next layer.

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake after leaving the vanilla ice cream layer to set in the freezer for 1 hour.

    Oreo Hot Fudge Layer, Toppings, and Garnishes

    After the ice cream cake has had time in the freezer, remove it and add a layer of the Oreo Hot Fudge cookie crumble on top of the vanilla ice cream layer.

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake after hot fudgy oreo filling was added to the vanilla layer and set overnight. Ready for the final toppings and cool whip layer

    Time for toppings! Spread a layer of Cool Whip topping over the Oreo Hot Fudge cookie crumble layer. This layer will hold all of the garnishes in place. Sprinkle more of both the Peanut Butter cookie crumble AND the Oreo Hot Fudge Cookie crumble into a healthy heap on top of the Cool Whip layer. Drizzle hot fudge and (optional melted peanut butter) over the heap and outer ice cream cookie edge. Use a Reddi Whip can to add dollops of whipped cream around the border of the cake and place braided, round pretzels around the border as well (just to be extra). Place back in the freezer for 4 hours or overnight before serving the cake.

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake

    When you are ready to serve the cake, release the spring form pan and peel away the parchment paper before cutting the ice cream cake. Also, most importantly, plan on making two of these if you happen to be serving as dessert for a gathering of more than 10 people. Despite the serving size, I always have people come back for seconds.

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Oreo Ice Cream Cake

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Oreo Ice Cream Cake

    ENJOY!

    Did you make this recipe? I wanna see!

    TAG @BINGEWORTHYBITES ON INSTAGRAM AND HASHTAG IT! #BINGEWORTHYBITES

    Peanut Butter and Hot Fudge Ice Cream Cake

    Callie
    Peanut Butter Hot Fudge Oreo Ice Cream Cake is a sweet and salty, crunchy, cold, and creamy dessert that's easy to make and sure to impress.
    5 from 6 votes
    Print Pin Save Saved! Email
    Prep Time 25 minutes mins
    Chill/Set Time 7 hours hrs
    Total Time 7 hours hrs 25 minutes mins
    Course Dessert
    Cuisine American
    Servings 12 servings

    Equipment

    Parchment paper, or cellophane sheet for cake collar
    springform pan
    Cooking or baking spray

    Ingredients
      

    • 8 ice cream sandwich bars
    • 1 pint vanilla ice cream
    • 1 pint chocolate ice cream
    • 8 oz cool whip
    • hot fudge

    Peanut Butter Crumble

    • 4 tablespoon butter, melted
    • 2 tablespoon peanut butter
    • 24 nutter butter cookies
    • 2 tablespoon milk

    Hot Fudge Oreo

    • 24 oreos
    • 3 tablespoon hot fudge
    • 2 tablespoon milk
    • 4 tablespoon butter, melted

    Instructions
     

    • Spray a 9" spring form pan with cooking spray. Cut thick strips of parchment paper and line the inner sides of the pane with strips. Strips will stick to the cooking spray.
    • Remove ice cream sandwiches from the freezer in groups of 4 (to prevent them from melting). Cut each ice cream sandwich into quarters and place each quarter against the edge of the spring from pan, forming a ring around the inside of the pan. Once ring is completed, place pan back in freezer.
    • Remove ice cream (for layering) and place on counter top. Allow it to sit as you complete the next couple of steps.
    • Place Nutter Butter Cookies in food processor. Cover and pulse the food processor until all cookies have been broken down to small crumbs.
    • Add 4 tablespoons of melted butter, 2 tablespoons of milk and 2 tablespoons of peanut butter to the food processor with the cookie crumbs and pulse until well combined. Remove mixture from food processor and set aside. Clean the food processor bowl and blade before proceeding to the next step.
    • Add Oreos to cleaned food processor. Cover and pulse the food processor until all cookies have been broken down to small crumbs.
    • Add 4 tablespoons of melted butter, 2 tablespoons of milk, and 3 tablespoons of hot fudge to the Oreo cookie crumbs and pulse until well combined. Remove from food processor and set aside.
    • Remove spring form pan from freezer and pack the peanut butter cookie crumble mixture into an even layer (about ½" thick) on the bottom of the pan. Cookie crust will be within the border of the ice cream sandwiches, do not attempt to put the crust mixture below the ice cream sandwiches. Use the bottom of a round glass or cup to smooth out the crust layer.
    • Warm the hot fudge and stir to make easily spreadable. Spread an even layer (about ¼" thick) of hot fudge on top of the peanut butter cookie crust.
    • Using a large spoon or silicone spatula, stir the chocolate ice cream within its container or in a separate bowl. Ice cream should stir easily ( a little softer than soft serve). Spread a pint of chocolate ice cream on top of the hot fudge layer on top of the peanut butter cookie crust layer. Re cover the remaining ice cream and put away in freezer.
    • Using a large spoon or silicone spatula, stir the vanilla ice cream within its container or in a separate bowl. Ice cream should stir easily ( a little softer than soft serve). Spread a pint of chocolate ice cream on top of the peanut butter cookie crust layer. Re cover the remaining ice cream and put away in freezer.
    • After completing the vanilla ice cream layer, place the ice cream cake in the freezer for 10-15 minutes to harden a bit.
    • Remove ice cream cake from freezer and add a layer of oreo hot fudge cookie mixture on top of the vanilla ice cream.
    • Top the layer of oreo hot fudge cookie mixture with a layer of Cool Whip (still staying within the inside border of the ice cream sandwiches).
    • Sprinkle more peanut butter cookie mixture and Oreo hot fudge cookie mixture into a heap on top of the Cool Whip.
    • Warm the container of hot fudge and drizzle over the cookie mixture heap. You can also warm up peanut butter and drizzle that as well (optional).
    • Use a Reddi Whip can to add dollops of whipped cream around the inside border of the icre cream sandwiches.
    • Add pretzels for garnish.
    • Place ice cream cake back in freezer for 4 hours or overnight before serving.
    • When serving, release the spring form pan and peel off the parchment paper before cutting.
    • Enoy!!

    Nutrition

    Serving: 1piece
    Keyword chunky peanut butter, cookie crust, hot fudge, ice cream, whipped cream frosting
    DID YOU MAKE THIS RECIPE?I wanna see! Tag @bingeworthybites on Instagram!

    OTHER DELICIOUS RECIPES TO TRY:

    click photos for links!

    • guacamole in mortar and pestle up close
    • Crispy Fried Zucchini with Marinara
    • Hawaiian Sweet Rolls
    • Vanilla Bourbon Peaches and Mascarpone Whipped Cream
    • Brown Butter Herb Crispy Skin Salmon and Vegetables
    • Greek Chicken Marinade
    • How to make the BEST Guacamole
    • Buttermilk Biscuit Peach Cobbler
    • Vanilla Bean White Chocolate Cheesecake with Fudge Brownie Crust
    • Peanut Butter Brownie Cups
    « Crispy Fried Zucchini with Marinara
    Potato Brioche Burger Buns »

    Reader Interactions

    5 from 6 votes (6 ratings without comment)

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    meet callie

    Hi, I’m Callie. Welcome to Binge Worthy Bites! Since my passions are food, photography, and bringing people together with delicious shared meals, Binge Worthy Bites came to life as a creative hub to share my favorite pictures + dishes with the world. What you’ll find here is a collection of recipes and tips that are sure to make your life a whole lot tastier. My site is dedicated to bringing you binge-worthy recipes that anyone can make, my hope is that each time you leave you’ll feel inspired to create. read more!

    Let's Connect!

    • Bloglovin
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

    Shop

    binge worthy bites shop cutting boards the collection

    search the website

    Recent Posts

    • Easy White Sandwich Bread Recipe
    • Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bread
    • Easy Baked Apple Cider Donuts (with Cake Mix)

    Footer

    Follow us

    signup For email updates

    Follow us

    signup For email updates

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Contact

    • Contact

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

    Copyright © 2022

    Copyright © 2026 · Binge Worthy Bites On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

    mancingduit linetogel angkabet fiatogel yoktogel hokijitu arena303 wdbos ziatogel arena303 pulitoto yoktogel wdbos tvtoto wdbos mancingduit togelup fiatogel arena303 ligabandot hokijitu ligabandot tvtoto nanastoto arena303 tvtoto wdbos latoto hokijitu ziatogel sinardunia88 togelup danatoto mancingduit arena303 latoto nanastoto lapak99 latoto yoktogel arena303 fiatogel bandar80 togelup ziatogel danatoto bandar80 yoktogel protogel wdbos wdmahjong bandar80 ziatogel mancingduit linetogel yoktogel tvtoto linetogel angkabet danatoto depobos fiatogel indratogel bosjoko jutawanbet latoto linetogel lunatogel mariatogel nanastoto oppatoto partaitogel protogel pulitoto togelup tvtoto udintogel watitoto wdbos yoktogel yowestogel ziatogel danatoto dingdongtogel fiatogel gengtoto goltogel hometogel indratogel indrabet jonitogel linetogel lunatogel mariatogel nanastoto oppatoto partaitogel patihtoto protogel pwvip4d situstoto togelon togelup yoktogel udintogel yowestogel ziatogel wdbos mancingduit latoto jutawanbet bosjoko tvtoto pulitoto angkabet depobos watitoto fatcai99 ruangwd topanbos88 hokijitu bandar80 lapak99 ligabandot juara88 topwd arena303 wdmahjong citawin markaswd hokbentoto angkabet bandar80 danatoto fiatogel hokijitu lapak99 ligabandot linetogel mancingduit pulitoto togelup tvtoto wdbos yoktogel ziatogel fiatogel linetogel linetogel nanastoto yowestogel tvtoto watitoto depobos depobos fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel nanastoto danatoto tvtoto depobos yowestogel yowestogel tvtoto yoktogel fiatogel fiatogel angkabet yowestogel fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel linetogel linetogel linetogel fiatogel yoktogel tvtoto citawin protogel togelup fiatogel fiatogel ruangwd hokijitu fiatogel yoktogel wdbos linetogel togelup fiatogel wdbos yoktogel togelup juara88 bandar80 linetogel depobos depobos depobos wdbos wdbos linetogel togelup togelup angkabet latoto linetogel wdbos wdbos yoktogel ziatogel togelup wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos bandar80 wdbos ziatogel bandar80 danatoto pulitoto togelup togelup togelup ziatogel togelup yoktogel linetogel wdbos Linetogel linetogel tvtoto tvtoto tvtoto tvtoto angkabet angkabet fiatogel ziatogel ziatogel ziatogel mancingduit bandar80 bandar80 ligabandot arena303 arena303 hokijitu topwd wdmahjong ziatogel nanastoto danatoto linetogel ziatogel yoktogel fiatogel togelup angkabet mancingduit wdbos pulitoto tvtoto bandar80 lapak99 ligabandot hokijitu arena303 topwd pwvip4d wdmahjong hokbentoto markaswd citawin juara88 fatcai99 ruangwd nanastoto hokijitu fiatogel angkabet mancingduit pulitoto linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel angkabet bosjoko danatoto depobos dingdongtogel fatcai99 fiatogel gengtoto goltogel hometogel indrabet indratogel jonitogel jutawanbet latoto linetogel lunatogel mancingduit mariatogel nanastoto oppatoto partaitogel patihtoto protogel pulitoto pwvip4d situstoto togelon togelup tvtoto udintogel watitoto wdbos yoktogel yowestogel ziatogel linetogel ziatogel wdbos protogel yoktogel danatoto pulitoto tvtoto togelup bandar80 linetogel ziatogel danatoto yoktogel tvtoto pulitoto arena303 lapak99 bandar80 ziatogel togelup mancingduit angkabet hokijitu wdmahjong situstoto danatoto wdbos citawin linetogel latoto topwd protogel togelup linetogel arena303 lapak99 latoto danatoto yoktogel ziatogel juara88 tvtoto situstoto wdbos depobos angkabet ligabandot zonatuan protogel linetogel fatcai99 pulitoto bandar80 wdmahjong sinardunia88 angkabet pulitoto pulitoto mancingduit mancingduit mancingduit linetogel bandar80 nanastoto linetogel fiatogel latoto ligabandot wdbos wdmahjong bandar80 angkabet danatoto ziatogel wdbos togelup danatoto pulitoto wdbos lapak99 linetogel danatoto mancingduit citawin zonatuan latoto yoktogel nanastoto ziatogel linetogel ziatogel fiatogel togelup mancingduit tvtoto pulitoto danatoto situstoto depobos lapak99 angkabet latoto ligabandot wdbos hokijitu ziatogel nanastoto tvtoto danatoto pulitoto situstoto depobos togelup protogel latoto wdbos fiatogel angkabet yoktogel linetogel wdmahjong arena303 pulitoto togelup protogel danatoto ziatogel lapak99 hokijitu latoto juara88 topwd fiatogel linetogel tvtoto yoktogel bandar80 ziatogel latoto wdbos arena303 danatoto yoktogel nanastoto angkabet fiatogel mancingduit tvtoto pulitoto wdmahjong ziatogel linetogel wdbos topwd angkabet fiatogel hokijitu bandar80 lapak99 ligabandot tvtoto danatoto bandar80 angkabet bandar80 danatoto fiatogel hokijitu lapak99 ligabandot linetogel mancingduit pulitoto togelup tvtoto wdbos yoktogel ziatogel fiatogel nanastoto wdbos depobos ligabandot citawin yowestogel fatcai99 wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos togelup togelup danatoto danatoto danatoto danatoto ziatogel ziatogel angkabet angkabet fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel fiatogel pulitoto pulitoto tvtoto tvtoto tvtoto tvtoto tvtoto mancingduit linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel linetogel yoktogel yoktogel yoktogel yoktogel yoktogel yoktogel yoktogel lapak99 lapak99 arena303 arena303 arena303 situstoto nanastoto togelup pulitoto wdbos linetogel fiatogel depobos ziatogel wdmahjong arena303 yoktogel danatoto bandar80 tvtoto ligabandot topwd nanastoto depobos hokijitu arena303 pulitoto tvtoto situstoto fiatogel bandar80 wdbos danatoto linetogel pulitoto wdbos zonatuan topwd lapak99 mancingduit tvtoto yoktogel wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos wdbos angkabet bandar80 danatoto fiatogel hokijitu linetogel mancingduit pulitoto togelup tvtoto wdbos yoktogel ziatogel wdbos linetogel protogel ziatogel tvtoto latoto danatoto situstoto togelup yoktogel pulitoto ligabandot arena303 hokijitu bandar80 nanastoto juara88 topwd lapak99 citawin mancingduit angkabet fiatogel wdmahjong ligabandot ziatogel yoktogel pulitoto tvtoto wdbos fiatogel citawin wdmahjong arena303 linetogel hokijitu bandar80 linetogel mancingduit fiatogel latoto danatoto togelup tvtoto yoktogel ziatogel angkabet pulitoto danatoto danatoto danatoto ziatogel danatoto latoto ligabandot FIATOGEL WDBOS TOGELUP LINETOGEL PROTOGEL ZIATOGEL DANATOTO TVTOTO TVTOTO DANATOTO SITUSTOTO TOGELUP TOGELUP WDBOS PULITOTO ZIATOGEL YOKTOGEL zonatuan topwd mancingduit tvtoto yoktogel ziatogel togelup linetogel indratogel jonitogel lunatogel ziatogel protogel nanastoto mariatogel linetogel jonitogel gengtoto danatoto linetogel gengtoto protogel oppatoto lunatogel linetogel jonitogel nanastoto jonitogel linetogel linetogel lunatogel mariatogel nanastoto nanastoto oppatoto partaitogel partaitogel patihtoto lunatogel ziatogel protogel oppatoto nanastoto lunatogel linetogel danatoto gengtoto pulitoto danatoto togelup nanastoto ziatogel linetogel yowestogel watitoto depobos depobos depobos yowestogel yowestogel yowestogel fiatogel linetogel linetogel fiatogel yoktogel tvtoto citawin protogel fiatogel ruangwd fiatogel yoktogel wdbos linetogel fiatogel wdbos yoktogel juara88 bandar80 linetogel depobos depobos wdbos linetogel angkabet yowestogel yowestogel mariatogel dingdongtogel linetogel hometogel mariatogel goltogel linetogel ziatogel protogel togelup togelup udintogel linetogel yoktogel yoktogel togelup yoktogel yoktogel danatoto angkabet bandar80 danatoto fiatogel hokijitu lapak99 ligabandot linetogel mancingduit pulitoto togelup tvtoto wdbos yoktogel ziatogel linetogel ziatogel arena303 fiatogel tvtoto togelup wdbos yoktogel linetogel yoktogel tvtoto ligabandot nanastoto mancingduit danatoto bandar80 wdmahjong depobos situstoto latoto arena303 bandar80 citawin danatoto depobos fatcai99 fiatogel lapak99 latoto ligabandot linetogel mancingduit protogel pulitoto sinardunia88 situstoto togelup watitoto wdbos wdmahjong yowestogel tvtoto arena303 topwd juara88 hokbentoto markaswd sinardunia88 togelup fiatogel ziatogel togelup nanastoto angkabet mancingduit yoktogel wdbos danatoto depobos hokijitu linetogel bandar80 fiatogel ligabandot lapak99 linetogel ziatogel protogel danatoto tvtoto togelup togelup danatoto pulitoto ziatogel linetogel ziatogel danatoto yoktogel tvtoto pulitoto arena303 latoto bandar80 ziatogel togelup mancingduit angkabet wdmahjong situstoto danatoto wdbos citawin fiatogel togelup linetogel arena303 lapak99 latoto danatoto yoktogel nanastoto ziatogel juara88 tvtoto situstoto wdbos angkabet ligabandot zonatuan protogel linetogel fatcai99 pulitoto bandar80 wdmahjong ziatogel fiatogel latoto zonatuan angkabet lapak99 lapak99 arena303 arena303 arena303 ziatogel markaswd ziatogel togelup wdbos yoktogel linetogel danatoto situstoto yoktogel tvtoto ligabandot bandar80 latoto togelup danatoto protogel mancingduit pulitoto danatoto tvtoto situstoto ziatogel danatoto togelup hokijitu situstoto protogel latoto depobos latoto juara88 angkabet fiatogel fiatogel latoto angkabet linetogel hokijitu wdmahjong bandar80
    41 shares

    Rate This Recipe

    Your vote:




    A rating is required
    A name is required
    An email is required

    Recipe Ratings without Comment

    Something went wrong. Please try again.